New City's Signature Holiday Ice Cream Pies Are Ready for Preorder✨

Holiday Ice Cream Pies preorders are back and ready! This year may feel a little different, so we wanted to bring nostalgic holiday flavors to life in ice cream form! Each pie is handmade with love in our scratch kitchen in Hudson, Massachusetts and features our signature ice cream, seasonal ingredients, and a handmade, buttery waffle cone crust. This year, we're offering three winter wonderland flavors:

Peppermint Stick Ice Cream Pie feels like being home for the holidays. We start with a sweet cream base, then crush peppermint candies by hand and add them to steep in the base releasing their fragrant flavor! It's extra delicious smothered in our homemade whipped cream.

Pecan Ice Cream Pie is our sweet cream base steeped with rich, dark molasses and loaded with candied pecans, topped with plenty of whipped cream and even more candied pecans.

Pumpkin Ice Cream Pie warms us up by the fireplace as our most over-the-top pumpkin flavor yet!  We use heirloom pumpkins that we carve up and roast in our oven to bring out those warm flavors we love. We mix those in with even more winter spices to create the perfect pumpkin ice cream, topped with whipped cream and a homemade caramel drizzle.

PICK UP is available 12/21-12/24 IN STORE ONLY. Preorder by 12/20 here. Please indicate Hudson or Cambridge pick-up when choosing your tickets.